When your mind keeps working on something you cannot change

Daniel J. Schwarz - Unsplash

Written by

in

A friend’s tone you can’t undo, a result you have to wait for, a decision someone else will make. When your mind keeps working on something you cannot change, it circles the same spot without getting anywhere. That isn’t a lack of willpower. The mind is simply built to keep looking for an answer, even when there isn’t one to find.

In brief: A mind that keeps working on something you cannot change isn’t broken; it’s trying to help. A simple distinction from ancient Stoic philosophy can point that effort somewhere more useful.

A very old way of sorting what is yours

The Stoic philosopher Epictetus opens his Enchiridion by dividing the world into what is up to us and what is not. In his account, what is up to us includes our judgments, intentions, and desires; what is not includes our bodies, possessions, and other people’s opinions. When your mind keeps working on something you cannot change, those two categories are often tangled together. This is a philosophical lens, not a treatment, but the distinction alone can make the load look different.

A calm sea for a mind working on something you cannot change - Unsplash
Photo by Daniel J. Schwarz on Unsplash

Putting it into two columns

Draw a line down a page. On one side write what you can do; on the other, what you can’t. Other people’s reactions, things that are finished, and results that haven’t arrived usually land in the second column. If the first column is nearly empty, that’s fine. Seeing the second column written down gets a thought that has only existed in your head out onto the page.

What you can do is usually small

The first column rarely holds a grand solution. It might be deciding not to message tonight, picking up another task while you wait, or writing your own view down in a sentence. Small as these are, they are clearly yours, and that tends to lighten things a little. Finding even one place where effort can land makes the helplessness feel less total.

This is moving effort, not giving up

Accepting that something is out of your hands can sound like resignation, which makes it heavier. But the distinction isn’t an instruction to quit. It’s an invitation to spend your effort elsewhere. You can’t steer the outcome, but you can choose how the waiting days go, and that choice costs far less than fighting the outcome itself.

Alex Diaz - Unsplash
Photo by Alex Diaz on Unsplash

When the thought keeps coming back

Some days the thought returns even after you’ve sorted it. That’s ordinary. Noticing it and quietly saying “this one is on the other side” is enough. Rather than cutting the thought off, count on noticing it more often; over time the loops usually get shorter.

Letting the body settle first

When a thought keeps circling, the body is often tense along with it. Dropping your shoulders, breathing out slowly, or standing up for a short walk is clearly within your reach. Instead of solving a mental problem only with the mind, loosening the body first often lets the same thought pass more gently.

Calm doesn’t mean feeling nothing

Stoic calm is sometimes mistaken for having no feelings. Frustration and worry are still natural. What changes is giving up the effort to erase them. Let the frustration be there, and pick one thing you can do.

Waiting for a result you can’t hurry

The time before a result arrives tends to feel the longest. During it, instead of trying to predict the outcome, it helps to pick one task for today and put your attention there. Predicting never produces a certain answer, but what you finish today actually stays finished, and that gives the waiting some shape.

Philosophy is a tool, not a verdict

Epictetus’s distinction won’t fit every situation. Where your part ends differs from case to case, and sometimes asking for help is your part. Treat it as one lens for looking at your mind, and set it down if it doesn’t fit.

When your mind keeps working on something you cannot change, in more depth

For a related read on this, see what to do when a thought keeps asking for an answer.

For more background on this idea, Epictetus is a useful starting point.

For general guidance on managing stress, see the NHS’s Get help with stress.

This article is for general information and isn’t a substitute for professional advice.